Evaluation of Teaching Ideas when Teaching Self-Identity

 For this evaluation I chose the book "Becoming Vanessa" by Vanessa Brantley-Newton. In this book, a girl named Vanessa prepares for her first day of school with an outfit that has all of her favorite clothing items. While she's at school she becomes self-conscious about being herself because her outfit is seen as a distraction by her classmates with all the questions and pointing out; but her teacher loves it. She also becomes self-conscious about her name because her classmates names aren't as long, so she tries to say that she is a different name. Once she's home she tries to avoid the day by ignoring that it happened at all. The next day, Vanessa wears an ordinary outfit that doesn't have the "personal touch" of Vanessa, and her mom helps her remember why she is so unique and how she doesn't need her favorite clothes to show that she is unique in her own way. Once she is reminded of the importance of her name and why she is unique and special, she goes to class and shares what makes her so special and unique. I feel like this book is a great way to teach students to be proud of their uniqueness and individuality. It could also be a great resource to help students be more comfortable and embrace the first day of school; help them come out of their shell, with the right activity :). In the two articles I chose, they both provide tips for providing an identity-safe environment, that students feel welcome and safe being themselves in. In the edutopia article by Becki Cohn-Vargas and Dorothy M. Steele, one of the tips given was "Every day (not restricted to a specific month or holiday), include diverse music, art, games, stories, and activities that reflect the backgrounds of each student". I feel like this is a great idea that can help teachers understand that learning about, and celebrating, identity doesn't just have to be during holidays, you can build personal, and self identity year round through mini-lessons or activities. In the second article from Understanding Prejudice, one of the tips given was "Make empathy training as central to your lesson plans as reading, writing, and arithmetic". This one is an important idea I feel, because empathy for others, when it comes to sharing things about self-identity, is important to have so that there is a judgment free zone during these conversations. Overall, self-identity is an important thing for students to understand and accept because, "without addressing each student's needs for belonging and value, we cannot successfully teach them". 


Resources: 

https://www.edutopia.org/blog/creating-an-identity-safe-classroom-becki-cohn-vargas-dorothy-steele

https://secure.understandingprejudice.org/teach/elemtips.htm






Comments

  1. I first want to commend you for offering a free resource and excellent synopsis on “Becoming Vanessa”! I was scouring the web for a free book and the world is not kind to teachers in that regard, even the library was letting me down with their e-books. I also think its fabulous that the book’s author is reading her book to the audience. This is truly a wonderful resource.

    Understanding Prejudice offered tips for the classroom that I felt were relevant to today’s society as well. One of the things I hit on was setting the tone for lessons by using inclusive language and offering diverse learning materials. You cited “making empathy training central to your lesson plans”- how would you inject these ideals into your classroom?

    What subject and grade level do you plan to teach? You also mentioned celebrating diversity every day, not just on specific holidays. You could have students contribute to your music, art etc., collection by having a list they can add to whenever inspiration strikes them and build your classroom community.

    I do have a suggestion for your next blog post. I found myself losing my place while reading your post since it wasn’t broken up and it all blended together.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Jess! For your first question I feel like SEL materials are a great resource when teaching kids about empathy and emotions so I would like to try that! For your second question, I would love to teach K-2nd, anyone of those :) Also I really love that idea of having a list that students add to! And thanks so much for the suggestion, so sorry I'll definitely keep that in mind.

      Delete
  2. Hey Tatyanna, I love the book you have chosen and how it talks about being confident with your identity. I like that you included that the classroom should be an identity- safe space. I feel like this is such an important topic for children because school can be very intimidating for some students and can cause them to be self conscious, I know I was. One suggestion I have is to create an activity with this book on the first day of school. The reason why I think this would be a great first day of school book is because it talks about the experience, and with this book the children will be able to understand that it is a safe zone, not somewhere where we come to judge others' identities. The activity would be to get a paper and write their name and if they have a meaning behind it. Once they have completed that step you can ask them to draw something that makes them who they are and makes them unique. I feel like as a kid I would have really enjoyed that activity because having a “boy name” was definitely an experience that made me self conscious, but over the years I’ve grown to love my name because of the story my parents have told me about how they chose my name. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Keith! I love that activity idea, thanks so much!

      Delete
  3. Hi Tatyanna, I enjoyed reading your book that you chose to highlight on your blog and how it teaches students to be comfortable in their own identity no matter what anyone thinks. This is a good book to introduce to elementary students as soon as they start going to school to teach them that everyone has their own identity and it is okay to be different and stand out as long as you feel comfortable then nothing else matters. It helps students feel more comfortable when they talk about what makes them unique and stand out because it can be hard expressing yourself. The book is good to use on the first week of school to let students feel more comfortable and the classroom will feel as a safe space for students to fully express themselves. I wish my teacher in grade school would have read this kind of book to me because it would made me feel more comfortable with being myself in the classroom and try not to fit in just because I was scared I might be judged.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mackenzie! I can definitely agree, I most likely will be using this in the future for the first week :)

      Delete

Post a Comment